An assistant professor and a faculty member at al-Mustafa International University
Abstract
In their study of Imamate issues, the Shiite scholars have referred to the words of Ibn Abi al-Hadid, the Sunni Mu’tazilite (D. 656 A. H.); nonetheless, some Sunni scholars have accused him of being a Shiite, a neophyte, an extremist, or even an obstinate Shiite. Now, the question is: are the words of such a person (Ibn Abi al-Hadid) valid and strong enough to convince the opponent in the course of Imamate debates? In what presented here, the author has drawn the conclusion that although he is a Mu’tazilite, in his The Commentary on Nahju al-Balaghah, Ibn Abi al-Hadid has strengthened the Sunnite and Ash’arite positions in the Imamate debates such as, that there is no clear text on the Imamate of Imam Ali (PBUH), that he is not the instant caliph after Holy Prophet (PBUH), and that infallibility was not specified as a condition for Imamate. Therefore, knowing him as a Shiite is either due to the lack of perfect knowledge about Ibn Abi al-Hadid or to the confusion of using terms. However, what matters is to follow the sound argument, rather than to blindly embrace the word of somebody. Thus, being a Sunni or Shiite does not work in the embracement of a proved and well-founded word. The motive of those biased Sunnis who have accused him might be Ibn Abi al-Hadid’s belief in Imam Ali’s priority over others, that he libeled Mu’awiah, or to nullify his criticisms against some Sunni beliefs, or to invalidate the Shiite documentations, or in order to refer to some of his words against the Shiite .
آلوسی، محمود بن عبدالله (1373ق). مختصر التحفة الاثنی عشریه. حققه و علق حواشیه. محبالدین الخطیب. القاهرة: المطبعة السلفیة.
ابن ابیالحدید مدائنی، عبد الحمید هبةالله (1378ق). شرح نهجالبلاغه (ج 1-2، 4-6، 8-9، 11، 14-18 و 20). تحقیق محمد ابوالفضل ابراهیم. بیروت: دار احیاء التراث العربیة.
ابنتیمیه، أحمدبنعبدالحلیم (1406ق). منهاج السنة (ج1و4). تحقیق محمد رشاد سالم. مدینه منوره: مؤسسة قرطبة.
قفاری، ناصربنعبدالله (1428ق). مسألة التقریب بین أهل السنة والشیعة (ج1). الطبعة الثالثة. مدینه منوره: دار طیبة للنشر والتوزیع.
مجلسی، محمدباقر (1403ق). بحار الأنوار (ج 15و37) بیروت: مؤسسة الوفاء.
مفید، محمدبنمحمد (1414ق). تصحیح الاعتقادات. چاپ دوم. بیروت: دار المفید للطباعة والنشر والتوزیع.
ـــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ (1413ق). أوائل المقالات. قم: المؤتمر العالمی للشیخ المفید.
مهدوی دامغانی، محمود (1375). جلوه تاریخ در شرح نهجالبلاغه ابن ابیالحدید (ج11).تهران: نشر نی.
واسعی، سیدعلیرضا (1386). جانشینان پیامبر9 در پرتو شرح نهجالبلاغه ابن ابیالحدید(نقد و بررسی متون و مستندات تاریخی). قم: پژوهشگاه علوم و فرهنگ اسلامی.